If you eat toast frequently, your life wouldn’t be complete without a toaster. They are quicker to heat than a stovetop, and since they have coils on both sides – something ovens do not – the toast is always uniform. Oh, and they have that satisfying ding!

From beans to a poached egg to kale salad, a modest piece of toast can make other modest foods seem like a satisfying meal. Soup is transformed into a cozy, delicious dinner from a spartan situation. Toast is typically made in the morning before coffee if you eat it as a breakfast item. Additionally, we strongly believe that nobody should have to deal with a frustrating kitchen appliance before coffee.  

Those with a large household or who tend to eat a lot of toast may be better off with the best 4-slice toasters as opposed to regular 2-slice toasters. Having chosen our top picks for their ease of use, ease of cleaning, and consistency, we sent them to our editors who tested them.

The testing included comparing browning between different types of bread (including frozen), toasting speed, and features such as Keep Warm and Bagel options. Did our editors’ sourdough slices, frozen waffles, and toaster pastries brown to perfection in these best 4-slice toasters? Discover the best 4-slice toasters in 2023 that you should have on your counter by checking our list.

1. Elite Gourmet Long Slot 4-Slice Toaster

You can toast oddly shaped slices of artisan bread with this toaster if you love sourdough boules or rustic loaves. With two slots that are 1.5 inches wide and 10 inches long, it’s generously sized to accommodate the majority of bread types. There is enough space for two sandwich slices, bagels, or English muffins in each slot. We are especially fond of the warming rack that can be flipped up from the top. Warm pastries, muffins, and buns with this.

Despite not having a bagel setting, this toaster features cancel, reheat, and defrost settings and six shades. Several of our testers felt that the various levels turned out burnt toast at the highest level. Furthermore, they noticed a bit of uneven toasting at the lower settings. With the defrosting setting, frozen slices come out medium golden, with crisp crusts and soft interiors.

We found the design of the toaster to be sleek and attractive on the counter, and it didn’t take up a lot of space. However, it felt cheap and lightweight. In order to match various kitchen styles, this toaster is available in three different finishes: black, stainless steel, and stainless steel and black.

You may also like:

• Best 2-Slice Toasters

2. Cuisinart Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

Among the most popular 2- and 4-slice toasters on the market are those from Cuisinart. It was nice to find that the four-slice toaster had two independent control panels. You can select different toast settings simultaneously if you prefer your bread well-done as opposed to your significant other.

The slots on the toaster are extra-wide, measuring 1.5 inches each, so they can accommodate thicker bagels and pastries. The cooker has an easy-to-use dial with six browning options, plus options for reheating, defrosting, and toasting bagels. With most toasters today, including this model, you’ll find an extra-lift lever that helps you remove the items you’ve toasted without having to touch the hot device.

The case is made from brushed stainless steel, so it looks modern with a hint of retro appeal. In addition to black stainless steel and metallic red, there are also stainless with white accents and stainless with black stainless steel. Keep your counters neat with the cord wrap and keep your toaster clean with the slide-out crumb tray.

Several reviewers have noted that this toaster is easy to use and consistently produces evenly browned slices. However, our tester had a little difficulty toasting bagels evenly.

3. Proctor 4-Slice Toaster

Among our testers, the Proctor Silex Wide Slot 4-Slice Toaster was recommended as a good, inexpensive, no-frills toaster. Although this model doesn’t have custom settings for different types of bread or defrosting frozen food, it has a few features that make it useful, including seven darkness settings, a cancel button, and a lift lever for smaller bread, such as English muffins.

With the slots wide enough, we were able to fit very large bagels, and the crumb trays were easy to reach. During testing, we found that toast browned unevenly at higher settings, as if some heating elements were hotter than others. Their favorite aspect of the unit was its sleek, minimalist design and easy and straightforward operation.

You may also like:

• Best Under Cabinet Toaster Oven

4. Cuisinart Compact Plastic 4-Slice Toaster

Cuisinart 4-slice toaster makes another appearance, this time at a slightly lower price. You will have to put up with a plastic body instead of stainless steel in exchange for snagging a bargain. This black or white toaster is unlikely to win any design awards, but it certainly doesn’t look bad.

Control is what you gain when you lose the design and build. Every member of the family can enjoy their breakfast made to order with 7 shades of gray, a class-leading feature. Each side of the toaster has its own control. The bagel setting is controlled by simple ergonomic buttons, as are the defrost, reheat, and cancel functions.

Despite generally positive user reviews, we did find some complaints about the flimsy construction and the consistency of toasting. This is a fantastic 4-slice toaster that won’t fail to impress if you’re looking for a cheap toaster.

5. Hamilton Beach Extra-Wide Shade 4-Slice Toaster

Hamilton Beach produces another fantastic 4-slice toaster with this product. Although this is a four-slot model, its slots are not as long and as wide as those in the previous model. Hence, it cannot be used with long slices of bread but works well with thick slices of bread and bagels.

There is even a special mode for bagels, one that toasts the inner portion and keeps the round outer portion warm. The goal here is to prevent burning on the outer side since both sides would burn if toasted equally. It also has the toast boost feature, which makes it easy to remove small slices, as the 24810 does. Also included is a shade selector that allows you to choose how brown you want your toast to be.

The toaster also comes with a defrosting function that can be used to thaw frozen pancakes and waffles. A feature of this toaster is an automatic shutdown once the toast is made. The buttons are also illuminated, so they can be seen even in dim light, which makes them more convenient for use.

You may also like:

• Best Microwave Toaster Oven Combo

6. Hamilton Beach Extra Wide Slot 4-Slice Toaster

Despite its stainless-steel construction, this toaster has two extra-long and wide slots that are capable of accommodating four slices of bread simultaneously. As well as toasting all types of bread, it can also toast bagels. In short, if you want something to toast more than just your regular bread, then you might want to consider this. The toaster offers three different modes: toasting, warming and defrosting.

One of its best features is that it keeps toast warm for ten minutes after making it. This is a very convenient feature as you sometimes don’t eat toast right away, and getting toast out can sometimes take a few minutes. This 4-slice toaster will keep your toast warm in such cases.

A shade selection option is also available on this toaster, so you can decide how brown you want your toast to be. Moreover, the buttons are illuminated, allowing you to see them even in dim light, which makes them extremely convenient to use.

Also, the sides of the building are designed in such a way that they remain cool even when the temperature inside is high. The toaster will not burn you when held or moved when in use. On top of that, you’ll also get a toast boost and the toast will pop up when it’s ready so you don’t have to struggle to remove it. Also, this toaster is the perfect combination of light, compact, and portable, enhancing ease of use and convenience.

7. KRUPS Breakfast Set 4-Slices Toaster

A brushed and polished stainless steel model from KRUPS is priced and sized similarly to our top pick, and reviewers who have owned it for several years say it toasts evenly every day.

Despite its generous size, the toaster slots have room for thicker slices of bread, bagels, and buns. To ensure even heating and browning, the slots self-center to ensure your toast is positioned precisely against the heating elements. Six browning settings can be selected on the dial. In addition, you can easily choose between two shades and a half by observing the hash marks between each browning setting.

You can select from defrost, reheat, and bagel options, and there is a high-lift lever to make it easier to remove your toast. Besides the removable crumb tray, there is also integrated cord storage. It comes with a two-year warranty.

You may also like:

• Best Toaster Ovens

8. Breville Bit More 4-Slice Toaster

Breville toaster makes several high-quality and competitively priced kitchen appliances. Its stainless steel construction ensures that this toaster will last a long time. The surface won’t rust or corrode, and it is extremely easy to clean. Furthermore, the stylish design will make this toaster stand out at the kitchen counter.

You can easily monitor the progress of your toast by looking at the LED display. Activating the lift and look function is also possible, although some users say that it doesn’t lift toast high enough. You can enjoy your toast to the exact taste you like with variable browning.

There are four slots on the inside, long and wide enough to hold four slices of bread. The self-centering guide allows for even toasting while preventing burnt edges or pale areas in the middle of the bread. You can hit the “a little more” setting to give your toast the finishing touches without burning it if it doesn’t seem quite right.

As well as this, you’ll also have settings dedicated to bagels and fruit bread, giving you plenty of flexibility when it comes to making breakfast. Breville 4-slice toaster may not be the cheapest on the market, but the combination of the build quality and performance makes it a great bet in a crowded market segment.

9. Breville Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster

Breville toaster die-cast with an 1800-watt motor has slots wide enough for the bread and bagels. Additionally, it includes toast, a bit more, defrost, and bagels settings that can be controlled via push-button controls.

Breville 4-slice toaster also features an automatic lower function and a lift mechanism to prevent burning when inserting or removing small slices. Furthermore, it can be used to check the browning of the bread at any given time by simply lifting and looking.

Toast is made using a beeping sound from the toaster. Additionally, there are six levels of brownness enabling you to precisely control the color of your toast. Breville die-cast 4-slice smart toaster can therefore toast bread to suit the preferences of each individual. A one-year limited warranty is included with this toaster so you can get it repaired in case of failure.

You may also like:

• Best Dualit Toaster

10. Zwilling Enfinigy Cool Touch 4 Slice Toaster

Known for its sleek design and high-quality appliances, Zwilling’s four-slice toaster didn’t disappoint our testers. A LED-lit control panel makes it easy to see all seven browning settings, as well as defrost, reheat, and bagel functions. You have the option of a soft lift as well as a high lift when your bread is done.

In our tests, our testers found that the slots were designed to position each slice of bread evenly for even browning. Everything came out evenly browned no matter what settings or types of bread I used with this toaster. Among the testers, it provided the most toasty coverage-there was no untoasted bread around the edges.

With the wide slots, they were able to fit bagels perfectly with the highest setting keeping the crust soft while keeping the interior dark and not burnt. The testers thought this toaster looked great on any countertop thanks to its very modern aesthetic. Accessories are also available as part of the Enfinigy line by Zwilling; they can be used for toasting sandwiches or warming buns separately.

11. Smeg Retro Line Cream 4 Slice Toaster

For those who believe that great kitchen appliances should also be beautiful, Smeg is the perfect choice. With a mid-century retro look without sacrificing functionality, this Italian brand collaborates with architects and designers. In addition to being delightful to use, these appliances are as lovely to post on your Instagram feed.

Toast is made to perfection with the four-slot Smeg toaster, which comes in vibrant colors and neutral tones. There are independent controls for each set of two slots, allowing you to adjust the brownness of four slices of toast individually. Browning, reheating, browning, defrosting, and bagel settings, as well as crumbs trays, are all included. Although it’s more expensive than our other picks, this toaster is beautiful and effective.

Buying Guide: Best 4-Slice Toasters

The 4-slice toaster’s price is one of the most important factors to consider when comparing it with other toasters. You will have to be a bit flexible with price and take a look at other features if you want a good toaster that meets your needs.

A toaster has a number of important features that you should know about. However, first, you need to know what you need. Defining your requirements and comparing products based on that list is therefore important.

Build Quality And Design

Choose the stainless steel or another metal toaster as they are more durable. Before purchasing, check the size and weight of the product. Some toasters are bulky and difficult to move around when the kitchen is clean.

The appearance and design of the toaster are also important as they can improve or spoil the look of your kitchen. So you need to think about what a particular toaster will look like in your kitchen.

Shade Selection

This is the feature you need to consider if you are one of those people who prefer their toast to have a dark brown color. There are a few toasters that allow you to control the brownness of your toast, but there are others that go above and beyond. For those who consider shade selection a crucial parameter, look for the best 4-slice toaster with nine or seven different settings.

You may also like:

• Best Convection Microwave Ovens

Slot Dimensions

Any toaster must fit the bread you intend to toast as a first and foremost requirement. As a result, you need to decide what your needs are first as not all toasters can accommodate large artisan bread and muffins.

All toasters can be used to toast bread for everyday use if you just need one for toasting bread. It’s best to get a toaster with larger slots if you frequently toast bagels, waffles, etc. It is therefore imperative that you check the slots in a toaster and see if they fit your requirements.

Number of Modes

Many toasters offer features beyond just toasting bread. Many toasters come with reheat and defrost options as well. By using the reheat mode, you can simply warm toast without further toasting. Thawing frozen waffles, pancakes, etc., is possible with defrost mode.

In some toasters, you can also set the toast back to “keep warm” mode after it has finished toasting. Additionally, this is quite handy for everyday use since you get warm toast even after a few minutes of taking the bread out.

Lift And Lower Mechanisms

The 4-slice toaster should have this function as it makes them easier to use. There are toasters that automatically lift while there are others that manually lift. Taking out even smaller slices of bread is easier when the toaster lifts automatically. Make sure the toaster has some sort of lift mechanism.

Frequently Asked Questions